?

Log in

No account? Create an account
heartbreaker

I'm feeling wanky tonight, so...

... allow me to make a rash and potentially controversial statement in the tradition of nostalgia_lj:

Kosh I is a bigot who plays race favorites.

(I don't think what I have to say will spoil andrastewhite, but I worry the replies might. Hence, the cut.)



The above statement stems from a question that has been eating away a back corner of my mind for sometime:

Why does Kosh intervene with G'Kar and never with Londo?

I don't buy that the answer is simply that Londo is "too far gone" to be receptive to the message. And a major reason I don't is Emperor Turhan's encounter with Kosh in The Coming of Shadows.

Consider what Emperor Turhan represents. He is the reformer, the man seeking peace, the man trying to turn the tide in his society and do something to atone for the mistakes of his world's history. He risks his health and, as we ultimately see, his very life to reach out a hand to his enemy. If anyone deserves to see a Vorlon sans encounter suit, it is he.

Yet when Kosh visits Turhan on his death bed, he remains shrouded. Why? Why, when beings of practically every other race are given the opportunity to see Kosh later that year, is this Centauri, who represents everything that is noble in sentient life, denied that experience? I realize they were in the Med-Lab, which is a public place, but couldn't Kosh have just cracked open the helmet a little? Or ordered everyone in the room to leave? Or entered Turhan's mind as he did with G'Kar? Or something?

Until someone comes up with a better answer, I can only conclude that Turhan is being punished for the sins of his fathers- that the Vorlons have decided that all Centauri, no matter who they are, are not worthy of their presence...

...even though I can name other Centauri besides Turhan who are in fact worthy.

*mumbleVirmumble*

Tags:

Comments

Okay, I suspect that it could be (see how I'm hedging my bets?) that Centauri just cannot see Vorlons without an encounter suit. Remember that Londo said he saw "nothing" when Kosh saved Sheridan? I thought at the time that it was because Londo himself was touched by the darkness.

Perhaps it's the Centauri as a whole?
I thought it was the Centauri as a whole too - like the Vorlons hadn't meddled in their cultures so there was no fitting illusion for Centauri to see?
Me? Rash and potentially controversial? Mad talk!
Wankers, the whole lot of them :D

I'm thinking that's the right reaction.

So yeah, screw the Vorlons and their wanky wankiness! *g*

He does, too *g*

One wonders if he would have interfered in Dust to Dust if, say, Londo had been about to kill Refa?

Otoh, he calls both Centauri and Narn a dying people. And on the other other hand, I like the thought of the Centauri not having been interfered with by the Vorlons (since we know the other races see them as their version of angelic beings because they have been genetically conditioned to).

However: the Centauri have telepaths. And telepaths supposedly were "engineered" by the Vorlons as well...

A sudden idea: Maybe the Vorlons made the wrong bet and conditioned the Xon, and not liking to be on the losing side have never forgiven the Centauri for winning the planetary race? *g*

:P

Oh, right. Because the fact that Kosh saved Londo's life made Londo's life so much better. :P More like prolonging the tragedy from where I'm sitting. :P

A sudden idea: Maybe the Vorlons made the wrong bet and conditioned the Xon, and not liking to be on the losing side have never forgiven the Centauri for winning the planetary race? *g*

That is the theory that soulonds9 and I are currently massaging. As I said, sins of the fathers- or greatXgoogleplex fathers, in this case. *g*

I always wondered...

...if Cartagia was really as mad as most people assumed he was, or if the assumption of his psychosis makes them miss something very interesting.

Because at one point Cartagia implies that the Shadows are the gods of his people, and given the Centauri's imperialistic history and rather survival-of-the-fittest-based political system, I wonder if the Centauri were conditioned by the Shadows. It wouldn't excuse the Vorlons' attitude to the Centauri, but it would be another interesting explanation for it.